aboutface-mobile-menu-hide_03
aboutface-mobile-menu-show_03
facebook twitter youtube tumblr share this

Body image gets animated: What The Simpsons and Family Guy say about beauty

Date: October 22, 2009 | Posted By:

For a long time, I have believed in the power of empathizing with a fictional character to transform the way we feel about ourselves. But how does this relationship play out when that character is not human, but cartoon?

Lisa from <em>The Simpsons</em>

Lisa from The Simpsons

In The Simpsons, Lisa Simpson stands out as a character very different to the rest of her family. She is intellectual, self-reflective and idealistic. So it should come as no surprise when she, just like any other real-life female, experiences body image problems.

In the episode “Sleeping With the Enemy”, Lisa is teased at school about her “big butt”, which sends her into a downward spiral of negative body image and unhealthy eating habits. She reads Thin by Third Grade and indulges in retail therapy — only to find a clothing store where a sales assistant planes down the thighs of a mannequin so it conforms to the new skinny standard. She discusses her feelings with Bart, saying, “I know that this obsession with thinness is unhealthy and anti-feminist, but that’s what a fat girl would say!”

<em>Family Guy</em>'s Meg Griffin

Family Guy's Meg Griffin

Lisa is not the only cartoon character to have body image struggles. Family Guy’s Meg Griffin is a socially awkward, self-conscious teenage girl who is generally mistreated by her family, and her appearance is often exploited in the name of humor.

In the episode “Barely Legal”, Meg is depressed about not having a date to her prom, telling the family dog Brian “I’m so fat and gross,” and threatening to kill herself.

Meg's replacement in her family's reality TV show

Meg's replacement in her family's reality TV show

In other episodes, her brother Chris draws pictures of her with a pig’s body, father Peter farts in her face, she is depicted as a bulldog, and she is replaced by a prettier actress when the family gets their own reality show.

Meg isn’t portrayed as intellectual, like Lisa, and therefore her body image problems are not as complex. While their crises both stem from being made fun of, Lisa has the ability to question it, even as she succumbs to it. On the other hand, Meg is not shown being critical of her own position.

As in real life, neither characters’ struggles are ever fully resolved. At the end of the Simpsons episode, Homer asks Lisa if everything is OK, but she refuses to say that she’s now comfortable with her body. Instead, she acknowledges that, like many women still obsessed by weight, she has a long way to go. The fact that the issue wasn’t neatly resolved meant that it was a little more thought-provoking than a typical cartoon happy ending. In Meg’s case, the jokes just don’t stop coming.

Do you relate to Lisa or Meg? Are cartoon characters an effective means of exploring body image issues?

–Tessa




What Do You Think?

5 Responses to Body image gets animated: What The Simpsons and Family Guy say about beauty

  1. Tweets that mention A B O U T – F A C E — blog » Body image gets animated: What The Simpsons and Family Guy say about beauty -- Topsy.com on 10-23-2009

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Pia Guerrero, Pia Guerrero. Pia Guerrero said: From out friends over at About-Face. http://about-face.org/blog/archives/1846 http://bit.ly/DHRxJ [...]
  2. Abed Yamout on 10-27-2009

    All women are self conscious, whether its nature or nurture. Thats why the diet business is so big. Although, i see the self conscious women more in the upper class. I know ive always been lower middle class and never had self conscious problem, but then again. im a guy and not american either.
  3. uberVU - social comments on 10-27-2009

    Social comments and analytics for this post...

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by pia_AdiosBarbie: Frome our friends at About-Face. http://bit.ly/y8P70...
  4. Body image gets animated: What The Simpsons and Family Guy say about beauty | Adios Barbie on 11-01-2009

    [...] Originally posted at About-Face [...]
  5. Emily O. on 12-06-2009

    I definitely relate to Lisa. I KNOW that the standards I try to live up to are not only unfair, but unreal. Not even the models I see look like the models I see- they are all airbrushed. It's really hard to be a feminist in America right now. I've struggled with an eating disorder for a long time, and I've ALWAYS struggled with having an eating disorder and strong feminist values at the same time. I HATE that people see the way my body looks, because I know that many women want to have my body- but in real life, I am so thin because I have a disease that not only makes being me intolerable and my life miserable, but may kill me. I wish that I was confident enough to, when walking around in public, carry a sign saying all of this on me.